4

Possible Duplicate:
should i update with results?

I haven't had this issue on other Stack Exchange sites, but cooking is maybe more clearly divided in a theoretical and practical side. When programming, a possible solution either works, or doesn't. A solution proposal may need some tweaks until it works, but each version is either fine or not.

In cooking, success isn't as clearly defined, and usually, nobody tests several versions back-to-back (alright, I do sometimes, but I think that I am the exception). I usually ask a question to help with a specific dish I am planning to cook, cook it, incorporating the best ideas from the answers, and evaluate my result based on several criteria like taste, texture, effort needed to prepare, etc. Even if I have ideas for how to make it better, they have to wait for the next time (which could easily be months, as I am always cooking different stuff, instead of perfecting a small number of dishes).

When I have posted a question and cooked the dish, I want to post about the results, as a feedback to the people who gave me the good answers, and advice/warning/suggestion to later readers who will find the question when they are faced with the same problem. But I don't know where to post.

An edit to the question itself feels strange. After all, the question should be solved at that point (hopefully). So I am not trying to explain more in order to get a better answer; I just don't need more answers.

A comment to the question itself also has its drawbacks. It is limited in size and formatting. Also, it would go under if there are a lot of others (maybe slightly off topic) comments.

Comments to individual answers only feel right if I have to say something about the answer itself, which is not always the case. Sometimes I just want to say "I used idea 1 from answer X, and idea 2 from answer Y. Texture was great, taste can use improvement." I cannot contribute texture and taste to one answer or the other, and besides, the report would be too fragmented.

Some time ago I saw an old question, where yossarian had made a report in an answer to his own question. So I followed this strategy in my own latest question. But it didn't feel like I was making a contribution worthy of its own answer. I didn't offer new ideas, just said that the existing ones had worked, and noted some issues with the dish (which could be, but are not necessarily related to the question). I felt that Sobachatina's answer was a really good answer, and that it deserved the accept. Usually, if I see a question where there is an answer at least as good as the one I could write, I don't write a new one, but upvote the existing one. And I have some kind of reserve against answering my own questions, probably created by the warning mechanism. Because of these two factors, it feels wrong to make it an answer.

As there is a drawback associated with all possible places for a report, I was wondering: is there some kind of ettiquete which says where to write one? Or is it discouraged to write them if they don't have enough information to qualify as a good answer?

  • 2
    This is a possible duplicate of should i update with results?. @rumtscho, yossarian asked a question just like this hear on meta before updating with results, which got a lot of great answers and which is why he did what he did. You can mark your answer community wiki (so others can more easily edit it and you don't get rep from it) if you feel uncomfortable with answering, but it is encouraged that you do update! – justkt Apr 5 '11 at 16:29
  • Sorry, that's what happens when I just don't think of the correct words in the preliminary search. I think I just searched for "report" then. Voted to close too, won't mind a mod hammer. – rumtscho Apr 8 '11 at 7:31
  • It's been.....hammered! – yossarian Apr 11 '11 at 17:12
3

I think this fits in fine with the philosophy of asking and answering your own question -- which is specifically allowed per the faq.

As long as your answer adds something to the question over the existing answers (if any), and is a legitimate answer to the question -- this seems like a fine approach to me.

(Particularly if you've waited a day, or several days, to see what the community has to offer.)

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .